Summary

Copper one Penny Token, minted by Heaton & Sons, 1858. Issued by Hide & De Carle, Grocers & Wine Merchants, Melbourne, 1858.

Thomas Hide and Edward De Carle formed a partnership in 1857. They had both been running their own businesses in Melbourne for several years beforehand. They founded a Grocery, Wine and Spirit merchant's business on Elizabeth Street, which lasted until 1861. Their business also included a land and estate agency. Hide and De Carle issued a total of 16 types of penny and half penny tokens, eight in 1857 and eight in 1858. All the tokens were struck by Heaton and Sons of Birmingham.

Physical Description

A round copper token (34 mm diameter) giving the name address and business of the issuer: Hide & De Carle, Elizabeth St. Melbourne, Grocers and wine merchants.. The token features at centre of the obverse a male lion standing to left with head crowned facing front, its right paw is raised and rests on a shield bearing the Union Jack, its tail curved back over its body. On the reverse a female figure representing Justice seated on a wool bale with legs to left but her head and upper body to front. A wine barrel lies on the ground behind her, its end decorated with a cross to hint at a Union Jack (as found beside Britannia on the copper coins of the period). A three-masted sailing ship sails to the right on the horizon to the left. Justice wears a blindfold and extends a balanced set of scales with her right hand. With her left she holds an inverted cornucopia from which fruits flow onto the ground. She wears an ancient-style of flowing dress bound at the waist, her left arm bare and right draped to near the elbow. It bears the date 1858. Token is worn on relief.

Obverse Description

At centre within two concentric rings of text devided by a beaded circle, a male lion standing to left with head crowned facing front, its right paw is raised and rests on a shield bearing the Union Jack, its tail curved back over its body. Around, .HIDE & DE CARLE. GROCERS & WINE MERCHANTS / . ELIZABETH STREET . MELBOURNE

Reverse Description

Female figure representing Justice seated on a wool bale with legs to left but her head and upper body to front. A wine barrel lies on the ground behind her, its end decorated with a cross to hint at a Union Jack (as found beside Britannia on the copper coins of the period). A three-masted sailing ship sails to the right on the horizon to the left. Justice wears a blindfold and extends a balanced set of scales with her right hand. With her left she holds an inverted cornucopia from which fruits flow onto the ground. She wears an ancient-style of flowing dress bound at the waist, her left arm bare and right draped to near the elbow. Around above; MELBOURNE. VICTORIA. in exergue; 1858

Significance

This token was sent to the Museum, unsolicited, by the donor. It was accompanied by a letter which stated:
'Dear Sir/Madam, Please find enclosed coin, it belonged to a great-great aunt of mine who owned a public house called the 'Eight Bells' in Watford, England, and was probably one of many old coins that got passed over the counter. I feel it belongs back in your great city and may be of some interest. I am sure that Hide & De Carle no longer exist, although Elizabeth Street might. Yours sincerely, Vivian Varley.'
Hide & De Carle tokens are not rare, and this example is not in particularly good condition. It is significant because of its provenance. Very few of the tokens in the collection have any provenance beyond the collector who donated them to the Museum. To know that this token was passed as either currency or a novelty in England, quite possibly more than a century ago, greatly increases its significance. It is concrete evidence of two way trade between Australia and England. The fact that it has been kept in the family for four generations is also of interest.

More Information

  • Collecting Areas

    Numismatics & Philately, Working Life & Trades

  • Acquisition Information

    Donation from Vivian Varley, Jul 2005

  • Date Issued

    1858 AD

  • Issued By

    Hide & De Carle, 41 Elizabeth Street, Melbourne, Greater Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, 1858

  • Mint

    Heaton & Sons (Mint), Birmingham, England, Great Britain, 1858

  • Place Used

    Watford, England, Great Britain

  • Inscriptions

    Obverse: HIDE & DE CARLE. GROCERS & WINE MERCHANTS ELIZABETH STREET MELBOURNE Reverse: MELBOURNE, VICTORIA. 1858

  • Denomination

    1 Penny

  • Series

    Trade Tokens

  • Material

    Copper

  • Axis

    12

  • Classification

    Trade tokens, Australia - victoria, Working strikes

  • Category

    History & Technology

  • Discipline

    Numismatics

  • Type of item

    Object

  • Dimensions

    34 mm (Outside Diameter), 14.41 g (Weight)

  • Shape

    Round

  • References

    Hide and DeCarle made issues of trade token penny and halfpenny denominations in 1857 and 1858. The tokens were manufactured by Heaton & Sons, Birmingham with well made and difficult to distinguish dies. The year 1857 saw the need for three obverse (called A. B and C) and two reverse (called 1 and 2) penny dies together with two obverse (called D and E) and two reverse (called 3 and 4) halfpenny dies. 1858 saw an additional two penny obverses (F and G) with four new reverses (5, 6, 7 and 8) while one new halfpenny reverse die was called upon (Reverse 9). Die breaks, changes of die alignment and the technique of die linking have permitted the full sequence of production to be suggested (see Sharples NAA 7 pp36 - 40). Token storage reflects the original sequence of production, while earlier catalogues aimed only to catalogue different die combinations. The dies were well made and clearly employed hubbing for the main pictorial elements. However, the entering of the lettering permits die identification even before characteristic breaks. Greatest accuracy of identification is by measuring spacing between certain letters or by specific letter alignment. Andrew's descriptions based on phrases like "less space", "higher" etc. make certainty of identification impossible. Summary of die characteristics 1857 Penny obverse dies Penny Reverse dies Die M to E E to T last T of Street Die E, to V A 3.5 mm 3.7 mm between NT 1 3.7 mm B 6.0 mm 5.8 mm between TS 2 4.3 mm C 3.0 mm 3.0 mm to N
    [Article] Sharples, John P. 1993. A Catalogue of the Trade Tokens of Victoria 1848 to 1862. Journal of the Numismatic Association of Australia. vol.7: p.1-77.
    [Book] Andrews, Arthur. 1921. Australasian Tokens and Coins.

  • Keywords

    Grocers, Wine & Spirit Merchants